Athletic All-Americans:
- Connor Toomey (hockey) 2011 Reebok NCAA Division III Men's Hockey All-American Second Team - West Squad, All-USCHO Third Team, Sid Watson Award (NCAA Division III Hockey Player of the Year) Finalist
- Austin Meier (basketball) 2011 Jostens Trophy Finalist
- Catherine Chappell (basketball) 2007 Jostens Trophy Finalist, 2007 NCAA All American (basketball, track and field)
- Brian Soik (hockey) 2007 Sid Watson Award (NCAA Division III Hockey Player of the Year) Finalist, 2007 NCAA All American (hockey)
- Matt Schoenherr (wrestling) 2004 NCAA All-American
- Matt Huset (wrestling) 2003 NCAA All-American
- Rachel Eggebrecht (track & field, indoor and outdoor) 1997-98 NCAA All-American (four times)
- Brian Guerts (basketball) 1991-1992 NAIA All-American
- Jeff Brezovar (basketball) 1981-82 NAIA All-American
Academic All-Americans, CoSIDA (College Sports Information Directors of America):
- Austin Meier (basketball) 2010-11 - Academic All-America of the Year
- Austin Meier (basketball) 2009-10
- Joel VandeBoom (wrestling) 2008-09 (second team, men’s at-large)
- Spencer Cook (soccer) 2007
- Brian Soik (hockey) 2006-07
- Matthew Schoenherr (wrestling) 2004
- Matt Hopf (basketball) 2003-04
- Chris Boardman (soccer) 2003 (regional)
- Rick Brooks (soccer) 2002
- Ryan Moren (hockey) 2000-01
- Rachel Eggebrecht (cross country) 1998
- Jeff Brezovar (basketball) 1981-82
